Smart Hacks for Better Makeup Drawer Organization

If you have a chaotic drawer full of makeup you don’t use everyday, there are some simple rules of thumb to help you pare it all down and put it in some kind of order.

A messy makeup drawer is a time waster. You’re digging for a lip balm while your eyeliner rolls away, and suddenly getting ready feels harder than it should. A few simple tweaks can make that drawer into your morning ally.

BTW I’m not trying to promote any brands. This is just the stuff I have, and I don’t feel like trying to digitally remove the brand names lol.

Smart Ways to Organize Your Makeup Drawer

Bonus tip: line your drawer with parchment paper to keep cosmetics from marking up the drawer. Parchment paper is great for this, but any thick paper liquid can’t sink through completely will work.

Purge Your Collection

Okay, this one’s basic, but if your drawer’s been chaotic for a while, this is a good time to see if there’s anything you can get rid of.

Start by emptying everything

Pull it all out. Yes, all of it. Lay your makeup on a towel or table so you can actually see what you own.

• Look for duplicates and expired products. Getting rid of those is a no-brainer.
• Check for near duplicates – two shades of lipstick you can barely tell apart and don’t really need both.
• Get rid of anything you’ve stopped wearing.

If this is hard for you – and it is for a lot of people, including me – ask yourself these questions:

• Does this item still fit with my style?
• When was the last time I used this product?
• Does this item still work and perform as it should? If it’s lost scent or visibly changed, chuck it.
• Do I have multiple products that really just do the same thing?
• Am I holding onto this for sentimental reasons, even though I don’t use it?

How To Tell What’s Expired

Makeup companies aren’t required to put expiration dates on products, so you have to learn some basic rules about how long they last and what to look for.

So here are the basic rules of thumb for when to get rid of different items.

• Concealer should be considered expired after 12 months.
• Eyeshadow: 3 years
• Water-based liquid foundation – 1 year, Oil-based, 18 months
• Lip liner – 3 years
• Lipstick – 4 years, but if it smells at all funny, toss it. You don’t want something that’s gone off near your mouth
• Mascara – 3 months
• Powder – 2 years
• Nail polish – about a year, depending on the brand

Can’t recall how old something is? Try to remember an event you bought it for or wore it to. If you’re not sure but it seems like it was a while back, just toss it.

There are also some tell-tale signs a product has gone off:

• Has the scent changed or gone away? Or does it smell funny? It’s probably not safe to use anymore.
• If it’s liquid, has it separated? If you shake it and it starts separating again soon, you should toss it.
• Has a waxy lipstick or eye pencil dried out?
• If it’s a powder product, has the powder started pulling away from the edges of its pan?

Pin it for later! ⤵️

Pin

Group items by how you use them

Now that you can see what’s left, let’s start grouping them. Organizing by brand, size or shape looks nice, but organizing by function works better day to day.

Keep face products together, eye products together, and so on. This mirrors how you actually do your makeup, which saves time.

If you do a quick routine most mornings, keep those “daily use” items in one section. Special‑occasion makeup can live in the back of the drawer.

Use drawer dividers?

Adjustable drawer dividers are a good investment, no doubt about it. They keep items from sliding around and let you change the layout as your collection changes.

That said, they’re not absolutely necessary, and you might even feel like they just take up room you don’t have. Or, like me, you might have an odd shaped shallow drawer that doesn’t really fit dividers nicely.

Pin it for later! ⤵️

Pin

Small boxes can do the trick, too. Sometimes the very packaging your makeup comes in can be part of a great system. The above photo is a repurposed Caswell Massey soap box containing eyeshadows, blushes, bronzers and pencil sharpeners. It’s very sturdy, and works well for this.

For small items like lip pencils or single shadows, shallow containers stop them from piling up. Think of it like silverware trays, but for makeup.

Store vertically when possible

Standing items upright saves space and makes labels easy to read. Lipsticks, glosses, and concealers are perfect for this. Small acrylic cups or even repurposed candle jars work well inside drawers.

That’s exactly what I use that repurposed soap box for.

Pin it for later! ⤵️

Pin

If your drawer is deep, add a second layer with a slim tray. That way nothing gets buried underneath.

Keep tools separate and clean

Brushes and sponges deserve their own spot. Store them away from powders to cut down on dust and fallout. A narrow container or divided tray keeps brush heads from getting squished.

Give tools a quick wash regularly. Clean tools make your drawer look better and your makeup apply better. Win‑win.

I personally prefer to keep brushes in a cup on my vanity, especially when I have a shallow drawer. This can free up a lot of drawer space too.

Arranging Your Makeup

Once you have your organizers in place, it’s time to arrange the contents. When arranging your products within the organizers, be strategic about placement.

Keep your favorites at the front. Put the items you use most frequently in the front and center, with less-used products tucked away in the back or on the sides. This way, you can quickly grab your go-to essentials each morning without having to dig through everything.

Consider organizing your products by color, texture, or product type to make it even easier to find what you need. For example, you could group all your cream-based products together, or arrange your eyeshadow palettes in a rainbow pattern.

There’s no single option that works best. It’s whatever works for you.

Makeup caddy? If you need more room, you can buy a makeup caddy and put some of your items in it. Use it to store either the items you don’t use often, and put it away, or use it to store the ones you do use every day and keep the less often used ones in the drawer.

What if Your Drawer Just Isn’t Enough?

If you get to the end of organizing and purging and making sense of your drawer, what happens if you’ve got more makeup than it really holds?

It’s not the end of the world. Sometimes you may just need additional storage. Fortunately there are so many clever organizers and drawers available these days, from clear acrylic dividers to rotating carousel towers.

Look for products that maximize the vertical space in your drawer or on your vanity:

• Tiered organizers or trays to separate makeup by category
• Lazy Susan or carousel organizers to rotate and access products easily (I love this one and use them all over the house)
• Stackable clear bins or containers to group similar items together

Take measurements of your drawer or vanity space and do some research to find the best organizers to suit your specific needs and the size of your collection.